My buddy from the dealer spoke with some people and they are saying it might be a gauge cluster issue. Once I'm done going to the track, it's going in to be checked.
PS- Ran my car last night and even though the dash isn't saying I'm in Sport Mode, I tried it anyway. Well, I had the best two 60 foot times ever so I think it's working even though the message doesn't show when you hit the button twice.
1.820 and 1.783