• Welcome to Ecoboost Performance Forum. Please log in or sign up.
collapse

Sealing Airaid Intake (Take 2) Comparison Modded K&N vs Stock VS Modded Airaid

Started by ShoBoat, August 09, 2014, 05:15:53 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

ecoboostsho

I actually tried the outside first quite some time ago. A lot of the box won't fit in the car with anything on the outside.

Sent from my XT1060 using Tapatalk

2013 White SHO w/PP, Gearhead Tuned, 3 Bar, 160T, Plugs...Mess with the Bull and you'll get the Horn. :)
Previous 2011 Tuxedo Black SHO w/PP - 12.89 1/4 Mile

slurppie

2013 w/PP
Synthetic blinker fluid
Ceramic muffler bearings

ShoBoat

Quote from: FoMoCoSHO on August 12, 2014, 07:35:44 PM
Quote from: jmr061 on August 12, 2014, 03:01:36 PM

Quote from: kinder on August 12, 2014, 02:52:11 PM
Quote from: jmr061 on August 12, 2014, 01:54:50 PM
I was thinking the same thing.   The product doesn't work as it should.  The company should design and provide free of charge a fix to better seal the unit. I pulled mine out as have many others because it doesn't work as it should.

It does work as intended.... for track use. Not strip or street but track. In motion it performs fine hence the fan driven dyno numbers.

But most of us don't track our cars. We street them and some take them to the strip. All these mods are to find a way to get the best of both worlds in one package. ;)

With that reasoning they wouldn't provide any weatherstripping at all since a seal wouldn't be desired. I'm calling them out.
Lol, I'm calling them out too. I guarantee that thing heatsoaks beyond recovery after anything more than a couple runs. The reality is its probably costing power in most scenarios. If anybody has datalogs showing otherwise, post em up and i will pull my steak off the grill and throw on some crow. Not only that, they will be the only option on record that that actually works. it is in their best interests to do the right thing. I will back up my words with cash in the form of an order for the improved unit, what say you Airaid?

A couple of things here, First without weatherstrip or bad fitting weatherstrip seal it's useless. Even tracking your car, if you are hard on the gas at higher speed you will be getting air that is hotter than ambient. I can attest to this with both the K&N and the Airaid. Even at 60mph you drop the hammer and the IAT goes up not down at least initially. I saw this effect first hand (both Airaid and K&N).

Secondly I believe that we have proved that a CAI can work if executed correctly. And that the stock box can be improved upon. The track runs that I did with the K&N, Airaid and Stock should be proof enough. And trust me, I was as surprised as the next guy with my results. That goes for all 3 tests. We are all about improving our rides, I did this primarily to help the guys that already had the Airaid myself included. I have data logs and time slips to prove what I stated with the raw data in my first post and the link to the K&N tests. The runs were all fair with about the same amount of staging time, with 3 consecutive runs with no cool down in between.

On the street I can state that the modded Airaid out performs both the K&N and stock box hand down. Lets face fact, anything you place under the hood is going to heat soak (Stock box included). The recovery from that heat soak is what really matters here. Again I believe that I also stated my results with that during theses tests. I am in no way saying to go out and buy an Airaid and then start modding it. You guys are absolutely correct it SHOULD HAVE COME THAT WAY IN THE BOX. Trust me I was pissed about that, but I got over it. I picked up 2/10ths on my 1/4 times. I am really happy with that, I wasn't expecting it but for sure happy. I am early waiting for my next mod (some new catted DPs from Power Parts) and then cool fall weather. And really see if I can't hit low 12.5s!

And Airaid, if you are reading this wake the F**K UP! For a $2 part you are really pissing off a lot of people. Christ, you are starting to look like GM. Oh wait did I say that out loud.




2012 Pearl White CTS-V Stock
2016 Fusion Titanium 2.0 EB Stock
2013 SHO Black on Black (Gone) PP, Unleashed Custom Tune, 170 TStat, SP534 Plugs, 3 Bar, Airaid Intake, PPE catted downpipes, Corsa Cat-back, H&R Springs. Focal 165KR Front Stage,2 JL W6 10 with Focal 800.1. 12.62 @ 110 mph.

TimmyATL

How might I aquire the correct rubber seal to start this modification lol.
13 SHO PP, Airaid intake, 170 T-stat, 3bar map sensor, Ecopower Parts hot side pipes, Turbosmart 7lb wastegate actuators, Stainless Works catted downpipes, Corsa cat back exhaust with Loudvalves exhaust dumps, Alky Control Meth Injection, LMS Dyno Meth tune. TSW Nurburgring  with NItto NTO5

panther427

Quote from: TimmyATL on August 13, 2014, 10:49:31 AM
How might I aquire the correct rubber seal to start this modification lol.

Right now it seems people are just going to parts or hardware stores or online stores to purchase extra foam or rubber strips.
2013 SHO

ShoBoat


Quote from: TimmyATL on August 13, 2014, 10:49:31 AM
How might I aquire the correct rubber seal to start this modification lol.

Call Airaid and tell them you want the D style seal not the blade. They should send it to you. You can then get the foam from the first post. You might want to hold off till tomorrow. I am in the process of testing the taller blade style strip that I got yesterday.
2012 Pearl White CTS-V Stock
2016 Fusion Titanium 2.0 EB Stock
2013 SHO Black on Black (Gone) PP, Unleashed Custom Tune, 170 TStat, SP534 Plugs, 3 Bar, Airaid Intake, PPE catted downpipes, Corsa Cat-back, H&R Springs. Focal 165KR Front Stage,2 JL W6 10 with Focal 800.1. 12.62 @ 110 mph.

jmr061

Quote from: ShoBoat on August 13, 2014, 11:25:11 AM

Quote from: TimmyATL on August 13, 2014, 10:49:31 AM
How might I aquire the correct rubber seal to start this modification lol.

Call Airaid and tell them you want the D style seal not the blade. They should send it to you. You can then get the foam from the first post. You might want to hold off till tomorrow. I am in the process of testing the taller blade style strip that I got yesterday.

No....airaid should send it all.  I shouldn't have to get a foam strip myself.
Jason
16 Edge Sport

ShoBoat


Quote from: jmr061 on August 13, 2014, 11:26:18 AM
Quote from: ShoBoat on August 13, 2014, 11:25:11 AM

Quote from: TimmyATL on August 13, 2014, 10:49:31 AM
How might I aquire the correct rubber seal to start this modification lol.

Call Airaid and tell them you want the D style seal not the blade. They should send it to you. You can then get the foam from the first post. You might want to hold off till tomorrow. I am in the process of testing the taller blade style strip that I got yesterday.

No....airaid should send it all.  I shouldn't have to get a foam strip myself.

In all fairness to Airaid, this is an improvement to their product. I did try out the taller blade style weather strip. And it did form a much better seal then the original one that came with the kit. My only concern is that it's not as playable as my design and pushes up on the hood a fair bit. It makes it harder to close the hood. It did a fair job of isolating the air from the box from the engine. As you can see from the pic below.





That said I'm going to keep my setup, it seals perfectly as good as the oem box. Airaid is sending me a D style weatherstrip at no charge. As the one I am currently using is from my old K&N and I have now sold that unit :). When I spoke to them today they said there was 2 reasons not to go with a sealed top. One was volume. They wanted as much as possible, 2 was cost. It would have raised the cost of the kit considerably.
2012 Pearl White CTS-V Stock
2016 Fusion Titanium 2.0 EB Stock
2013 SHO Black on Black (Gone) PP, Unleashed Custom Tune, 170 TStat, SP534 Plugs, 3 Bar, Airaid Intake, PPE catted downpipes, Corsa Cat-back, H&R Springs. Focal 165KR Front Stage,2 JL W6 10 with Focal 800.1. 12.62 @ 110 mph.

jmr061

So they admit they thought it better to allow hot engine air into a cold air intake. I'm sorry....that's bad business and false advertising.
Jason
16 Edge Sport

ShoBoat

I don't believe I said that, Christ get over it. 99% of CAIs sold don't do s***. In fact they hurt power. We just showed you how to get a decent increase to intake with a simple $10 mod. All the other intakes I have seen (including my old K&N) can't be made to perform as good as the stock intake. When I called K&N you know what they said? It made more power on the dyno and that's what we stated in our claims. So basically go F*** yourself. Airaid has done what they can to help me out and I have to give them props for that. I asked for taller they sent it to me. I asked for the D style weatherstrip and they are sending that too. So if you bought one spend the $10 to make it work better that it was even intended to. If not list it for sale. I'll bet you someone will buy it up quick! I had a hell of a time unloading my K&N.
2012 Pearl White CTS-V Stock
2016 Fusion Titanium 2.0 EB Stock
2013 SHO Black on Black (Gone) PP, Unleashed Custom Tune, 170 TStat, SP534 Plugs, 3 Bar, Airaid Intake, PPE catted downpipes, Corsa Cat-back, H&R Springs. Focal 165KR Front Stage,2 JL W6 10 with Focal 800.1. 12.62 @ 110 mph.

FoMoCoSHO

Quote from: ShoBoat on August 13, 2014, 02:24:48 PM

Quote from: jmr061 on August 13, 2014, 11:26:18 AM
Quote from: ShoBoat on August 13, 2014, 11:25:11 AM

Quote from: TimmyATL on August 13, 2014, 10:49:31 AM
How might I aquire the correct rubber seal to start this modification lol.

Call Airaid and tell them you want the D style seal not the blade. They should send it to you. You can then get the foam from the first post. You might want to hold off till tomorrow. I am in the process of testing the taller blade style strip that I got yesterday.

No....airaid should send it all.  I shouldn't have to get a foam strip myself.

In all fairness to Airaid, this is an improvement to their product. I did try out the taller blade style weather strip. And it did form a much better seal then the original one that came with the kit. My only concern is that it's not as playable as my design and pushes up on the hood a fair bit. It makes it harder to close the hood. It did a fair job of isolating the air from the box from the engine. As you can see from the pic below.





That said I'm going to keep my setup, it seals perfectly as good as the oem box. Airaid is sending me a D style weatherstrip at no charge. As the one I am currently using is from my old K&N and I have now sold that unit :). When I spoke to them today they said there was 2 reasons not to go with a sealed top. One was volume. They wanted as much as possible, 2 was cost. It would have raised the cost of the kit considerably.
Right, cause us guys buying $47k cars couldn't afford a pricier CAI that actually works.

And by their volume comment, they obviously have no idea what happens to the density of air when it's heated.

FoMoCoSHO

Quote from: ShoBoat on August 13, 2014, 02:37:40 PM
I don't believe I said that, Christ get over it. 99% of CAIs sold don't do s***. In fact they hurt power. We just showed you how to get a decent increase to intake with a simple $10 mod. All the other intakes I have seen (including my old K&N) can't be made to perform as good as the stock intake. When I called K&N you know what they said? It made more power on the dyno and that's what we stated in our claims. So basically go F*** yourself. Airaid has done what they can to help me out and I have to give them props for that. I asked for taller they sent it to me. I asked for the D style weatherstrip and they are sending that too. So if you bought one spend the $10 to make it work better that it was even intended to. If not list it for sale. I'll bet you someone will buy it up quick! I had a hell of a time unloading my K&N.
You didn't say it, they did, if your description of the conversation is accurate.

I'm really not sure why you're being hostile to JMR, he's not the one screwing us, it's AIRAID and K&N. You've done the hard work to prove it and I'm pretty sure everybody here appreciates it. I know I do as you saved me from wasting another couple hundred bucks on another product that flat out doesn't work.

You may be OK with modding the box you already spent cash on but there are others who may not. Personally, I'm at the point in my life, I'm not interested in working on my car, I pay people to put high quality products on my car. I'd rather be driving it.

This is a discussion forum made up of peoples opinions, not just yours, please respect those that have different opinions than yourself.

SHOnUup

Just a bummer they felt making it "work better" or "as it should", was sacrificed for price point it looks. Hey, it's America, at least the persistence by ShoBoat found a solution.
2011 Sterling Gray Metallic SHO non PP,
12.4211 @ 110.28 Livernois 3bar tune & CAI,
Added since...PPE catless Dpipes, Megan coilovers, Powergrid adjustable end links, and EBC slotted rotors and red stuff pads.
Tommy Designs grille with carbon fiber hydrographics, fender badges and fog bezels hydrodipped also, tinted windows, head & taillights, debadged trunk with all chrome plasti-dipped, black calipers, obdlink mx scantool running torque pro on 7" tablet.

ShoBoat


Quote from: FoMoCoSHO on August 13, 2014, 03:36:40 PM
Quote from: ShoBoat on August 13, 2014, 02:37:40 PM
I don't believe I said that, Christ get over it. 99% of CAIs sold don't do s***. In fact they hurt power. We just showed you how to get a decent increase to intake with a simple $10 mod. All the other intakes I have seen (including my old K&N) can't be made to perform as good as the stock intake. When I called K&N you know what they said? It made more power on the dyno and that's what we stated in our claims. So basically go F*** yourself. Airaid has done what they can to help me out and I have to give them props for that. I asked for taller they sent it to me. I asked for the D style weatherstrip and they are sending that too. So if you bought one spend the $10 to make it work better that it was even intended to. If not list it for sale. I'll bet you someone will buy it up quick! I had a hell of a time unloading my K&N.
You didn't say it, they did, if your description of the conversation is accurate.

I'm really not sure why you're being hostile to JMR, he's not the one screwing us, it's AIRAID and K&N. You've done the hard work to prove it and I'm pretty sure everybody here appreciates it. I know I do as you saved me from wasting another couple hundred bucks on another product that flat out doesn't work.

You may be OK with modding the box you already spent cash on but there are others who may not. Personally, I'm at the point in my life, I'm not interested in working on my car, I pay people to put high quality products on my car. I'd rather be driving it.

This is a discussion forum made up of peoples opinions, not just yours, please respect those that have different opinions than yourself.

Wow, I did state my opinion lol. So I should shut up? How do you figure? Look you guys are pissed I get that. So was I. Then call Airaid and flip out on them. Most of the comments I have seen here and on other forums is that it didn't work and they are collecting dust on some shelf in their garage.  With the combined efforts on here we made the damn thing work. Better than any other CAI on the market for our cars right now.

Ok let me see if I can make this clear one last time lol. We took Airaid's intake and made it better. Tell me you have never done that to a product? Did it work as advertised, no not really. Can it be made to work? Yes. I am ok with that, because I already own one.
I would be a lot more pissed if it was the K&N that couldn't even be made to work.

I didn't mean to offend anyone. Just stating my opinion too lol.
2012 Pearl White CTS-V Stock
2016 Fusion Titanium 2.0 EB Stock
2013 SHO Black on Black (Gone) PP, Unleashed Custom Tune, 170 TStat, SP534 Plugs, 3 Bar, Airaid Intake, PPE catted downpipes, Corsa Cat-back, H&R Springs. Focal 165KR Front Stage,2 JL W6 10 with Focal 800.1. 12.62 @ 110 mph.

ShoBoat


Quote from: SHOnUup on August 13, 2014, 03:44:59 PM
Just a bummer they felt making it "work better" or "as it should", was sacrificed for price point it looks. Hey, it's America, at least the persistence by ShoBoat found a solution.

It wasn't just me, the work on this intake was started by others on here. I just added my own flair. It was a collaboration of efforts that resulted in the outcome.   
2012 Pearl White CTS-V Stock
2016 Fusion Titanium 2.0 EB Stock
2013 SHO Black on Black (Gone) PP, Unleashed Custom Tune, 170 TStat, SP534 Plugs, 3 Bar, Airaid Intake, PPE catted downpipes, Corsa Cat-back, H&R Springs. Focal 165KR Front Stage,2 JL W6 10 with Focal 800.1. 12.62 @ 110 mph.