For black Friday, I picked up a Gearhead Automotive Performance tune; SCT x4 and GH gapped plugs. I also got a 3 bar from Rock Auto.
12/18- My plan was to install all at the same time, however several weeks later and I just could not be patient anymore. So in about 30min I had everything but the plugs done. A few road trips later and my impressions are this: not much noticeable difference. First and second gear appear to be more aggressive, firmer shifts, and even though I question it myself- the exhaust note sounds better.
Up until the tune, OAR had been -1.0000 for over year (93 plus ACES IV). Since the tune, its slowly crept up, and is currently sitting at -0.3828. Most of the drives shows timing at +40, but there are times when its retarded a few degrees. I think both of these are due to using stock plugs, but could also be changes caused by the tune's usage of OAR (GH specifies that they improve the auto octane adjustment feature, but I dont know much more detail).
12/30- I have changed the plugs and scoped each cylinder. I'll keep using the torque app to see if there is any improvement. Using this cylinder order, all of the plugs and tops of the pistons looked good. I could see the 'thumb print' in great detail on every piston. Car has 37,6xx miles
Firewall
1 2 3
4 5 6
Bumper
#2 I could actually see a QR code and other (model number or something) markings.
#1 and #3 were the 'worst'. Those two have slight amounts of carbon build up, mostly in the center indentation around the 'thumb print'.
4-6 were almost as clean as 2, though the position of the pistons prevented me from seeing any markings. Tops of pistons looked good.
I did notice I have what appears to be leaking around the HPFP. Is this normal, and easy to fix. This concerns me some, but I hope its an easy fix using a seal or gasket.
Hopefully this fixes any timing retard. I'm less concerned with OAR at this point, though since its increased after so long with it glued to the max value, I'd simply like to know what is causing the increase. A part of me also thinks that because of the increase is OAR value, I'm leaving performance on the table... and I dont want to do that

I'm also lining up a dyno session to see if I get numbers that mimic GH's advertised 335hp/415tq. I really hope I reach those numbers and my general impression of "not much noticeable difference" would be very welcomed as in my mind that would mean the tune has kept the stock drive-ability but actually added performance. As far as cylinders 1 and 3 go, I guess my options are: catch can; meth; or BG/ walnut blasting. I'll give it some time and take a look at the intake manifold before I make a final determination, since these are just barely showing signs of build up. My foremost concern is the gunk around the HPFP, and fixing any potential leak.