Thanks SHO! I think that, based on his description, he had an 0-ring leaking. A leaking 0-ring around one of the front spark plug holes on the valve cover would make sense for the discoloration of the COP's and the oily residue.
I had an '89 and '92 SHO and they both developed leaks there, but that was with over 200,000 miles. I wonder if the PCV system is clogged and it built up pressure and blew out an O-ring?
I will clean it up and pull the COP's out and see if there's oil in the holes. It's under warranty, but I like to know exactly what, if anything, is wrong before I take it in.