Thanks AJP for the numbers! Work and my 20 month old have keep me tied up and not focused on my toys. So, visual queues aside, the PP pad has more swept area.
Josephm--I agree with what you and AJP are saying, however I think you have your variables wrong in your statement. P=F/A, so solving for Force, then F=(P)(A). Force is the variable that is constant and is what is being supplied by the hydraulics on the pad (Area). So, if Force is contant, Pressure changes invariably with Area.
Now as mentioned by SHOdded, we could have loads and loads of Pressure (or even Force if we actually increase that in the system) but it would be useless without available friction. Since both pads are assumed to have the same CoF, higher swept area is better. Is there a point where the higher Pressure would trump higher Area, for a given CoF? Probably so, but I don't think our given system would supply. Ford designed PP pad has more area and was copied by EBC.