Thanks for the replies.
Just spoke with an attorney friend. He wants me to get the estimate from a Ford dealer, tack on $3,500.00 for depreciation, and add rental car costs. If the guy balks, he gets one phone call from the attorney. If he still doesn't pay up, we go immediately to his insurance.
My attorney's reasoning for wanting me to go after loss of value, is that it could come out a later date that damage occurred with paint gauges and other detection methods.